kasie-tutor said:
I think most students use the term FOIL when they just mean "multiply" and "solve" when they mean "find the answer."
Students might know what they're pretty sure they really meant, but when they use specific terms in specific ways, the listener can hardly be faulted for taking them at their word. :wink:
In my (admittedly limited) experience, when a student says "FOIL", he mean exactly that: the application of the one algorithm that he learned for multiplying binomials, but which he thinks must be the process for multiplying all polynomials. This very common mistaken understanding has led many instructors nowadays to strive to avoid "FOIL". It seems to cause more problems than it solves. :shock:
(I can't think of a time when a student ever said "solve by FOIL" but really meant "simplify the product of these non-binomials, and yes, I understand the difference." In fact, a great proportion of the questions which arise regarding "FOIL" are precisely what was seen here: The student thinks that "FOIL" is all there is to multiplying any two polynomials, and has no idea how to approach the simplification of the product of anything other than two binomials.)
While math helpers might indeed be needlessly and overly literal (an assumption I do not assert), the alternative seems generally to work rather less well. Trying to read a student's mind, making assumptions regarding what he "really" meant, is naturally fraught with error, and answering the question that one has decided that the student
really meant to ask-- well, it generally just ticks the student off. :evil:
Mathematics is a literal process, pretty much by definition. And students aren't usually looking to get "a discussion in the same general topic area", but the exact and literal value to an exact and literal exercise. When there is confusion regarding the question statement, it seems (to me) generally to be most helpful, in order to provide the literal help requested, to determine the literal meaning of the post. And, as in this case, when a student states that he is required to use a particular method in a situation to which that method does not apply, it seems only reasonable (and fair to the student) to point out the potential problem, and to attempt clarification.
The above is just my opinion, of course; I could be wrong....
Eliz.