Not sure how to work this

Richard B

New member
Joined
Feb 7, 2020
Messages
25
Find all values of
$x$
such that
\[\frac{x}{x - 5} = \frac{4}{x - 4}.\]
.
 
I worked through the problem and got 0, 2, 3, 6 but when I plugged in my answers to double-check they were wrong.
 
Last edited:
i worked through the problem and got 0, 2, 3, 6 but when i checked my answer and it was wrong
Please share your work - how did you get those values?

If I were to do this problem- I'll multiply both sides by (x-4) * (x-5)...........(with the restriction that x \(\displaystyle \ne 4 \ \ or \ne 5 \)), to get:

x * (x-4) = 4 * (x-5)

and continue...
 
[MATH]x=\frac{4x-20}{x-4}[/MATH][MATH](x-4)x=4x-20[/MATH][MATH]x^2-4x=4x-20[/MATH][MATH]x^2-4x-4x+20=0[/MATH][MATH]x^2-4x-4x+20-4=-4[/MATH][MATH](x-4)^2= -4[/MATH][MATH](x-4)(x-4)=-4[/MATH](2)(-2)=-4
(-2)(2)=-4
(-1)(4)=-4
(-4)(1) =-4

so x=
0,2,3,6.
 
I just did what you recommended, and I got
x(x-4)=4(x-5)
x^2-4x=4x-20
x^2-4x-4x+20=0

Which gives me the same wrong answer
 
I just did what you recommended, and I got
x(x-4)=4(x-5)
x^2-4x=4x-20
x^2-4x-4x+20=0

Which gives me the same wrong answer
It should not.

x2 - 8*x + 20 = 0

This is a quadratic equation. Have you been taught about quadratic equation?
 
[MATH]x=\frac{4x-20}{x-4}[/MATH][MATH](x-4)x=4x-20[/MATH][MATH]x^2-4x=4x-20[/MATH][MATH]x^2-4x-4x+20=0[/MATH]
Using the quadratic equation I get [math]x = 4 \pm 2i[/math].

You can complete the square, as you were doing:
[math]x^2 - 8x + 20 = 0[/math]
[math]x^2 - 8x + 20 - 4 = -4[/math]
[math](x - 4)^2 = -4[/math]
[math]x - 4 = \sqrt{-4} = \pm 2i[/math]
[math]x = 4 \pm 2i[/math]
(2)(-2)=-4
(-2)(2)=-4
(-1)(4)=-4
(-4)(1) =-4

so x=
0,2,3,6.
I have no idea what you are doing here.

-Dan
 
[MATH]x=\frac{4x-20}{x-4}[/MATH][MATH](x-4)x=4x-20[/MATH][MATH]x^2-4x=4x-20[/MATH][MATH]x^2-4x-4x+20=0[/MATH][MATH]x^2-4x-4x+20-4=-4[/MATH][MATH](x-4)^2= -4[/MATH][MATH](x-4)(x-4)=-4[/MATH](2)(-2)=-4
(-2)(2)=-4
(-1)(4)=-4
(-4)(1) =-4

so x=
0,2,3,6.
I agree with (2)(-2)=-4, (-2)(2)=-4, (-1)(4)=-4, (-4)(1) =-4, although I do not know why you stating this. I am extremely curious how did you conclude that x must therefore equal to 0, 2, 3 and 6.
 
Top