Adamantine Chains
New member
- Joined
- Jan 29, 2016
- Messages
- 4
Problem 2, Problem Set 1.2, From Strang's Linear Algebra and Its
Applications:
[Apologies for the poorly reproduced spacing; that should look like a
Triangular system]
(1) I do not know what form the solution should take. Thus far in the
chapter his examples involve unknown x (in Ax = b), not unknown b. This
looks as if it has an infinite number of solutions.
(2) There is no answer in the appendix. I cannot reverse engineer the
solution and thereby gain an understanding of the concepts.
(3) I found an answer online, but it does not provide enough explanation
for understanding. Here is that answer:
I don't understand how this solves anything. The row reduction is clear
(that did help to a degree), but I don't see why (b1 + b2), etc., are
coefficients (x), and I don't see why this should be viewed as a solution.
I'm missing some theory here. Any help would be appreciated.
Applications:
Solve to find a combination of the columns that equals b:
u - v - w = b1
v + w = b2
w = b3.
[Apologies for the poorly reproduced spacing; that should look like a
Triangular system]
(1) I do not know what form the solution should take. Thus far in the
chapter his examples involve unknown x (in Ax = b), not unknown b. This
looks as if it has an infinite number of solutions.
(2) There is no answer in the appendix. I cannot reverse engineer the
solution and thereby gain an understanding of the concepts.
(3) I found an answer online, but it does not provide enough explanation
for understanding. Here is that answer:
The answer will depend on what b is. So, your answer should
somehow involve b_1, b_2 and b_3.
To solve, row reduce the matrix
[1 -1 -1 | b_1]
[0 1 1 | b_2]
[0 0 1 | b_3]
to get
[1 0 0 | b_1 + b_2]
[0 1 0 | b_2 - b_3 ]
[0 0 1 | b_3 ]
The values in the right column give you the proper coefficients to write
(b_1, b_2, b_3) as a linear combination of the columns. In other words,
(b_1 + b_2)(1, 0, 0) + (b_2 - b_3)(-1, 1, 0) + (b_3)(-1, 1, 1) = (b_1,
b_2, b_3)
I don't understand how this solves anything. The row reduction is clear
(that did help to a degree), but I don't see why (b1 + b2), etc., are
coefficients (x), and I don't see why this should be viewed as a solution.
I'm missing some theory here. Any help would be appreciated.