infinely far away

shahar

Full Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2018
Messages
519
In the end of the article:
Escher said:
As all these strings of fish shoot up like rockets from infinitely far away, perpendicularly from the boundary, and fall back again whence they came, not one single component ever reaches the edge.
What the meaning of the expression "from infinitely far away"?
 
The article is about Escher's drawing of fish on a model of the hyperbolic plane. In the Google English translation, it says,
For example, the distance between the center of the circle and any point on the edge is defined to be infinite. This property is mentioned in the words in which [Escher] describes the print, about the fish that break out of the edge of the circle perpendicular to it, from infinity, and return to the place from which they came.​
As all these strings of fish shoot up like rockets from infinitely far away, perpendicularly from the boundary, and fall back again whence they came. not one single component ever reaches the edge​

1744685436292.jpeg

So a fish on an arc from the edge is considered to be moving in from "infinitely far away", meaning that when it is at the edge it is an infinite distance, as defined in this model, from the center.

Have you understood the article? You may need to read more about this:

 
The article is about Escher's drawing of fish on a model of the hyperbolic plane. In the Google English translation, it says,
For example, the distance between the center of the circle and any point on the edge is defined to be infinite. This property is mentioned in the words in which [Escher] describes the print, about the fish that break out of the edge of the circle perpendicular to it, from infinity, and return to the place from which they came.​
As all these strings of fish shoot up like rockets from infinitely far away, perpendicularly from the boundary, and fall back again whence they came. not one single component ever reaches the edge​

View attachment 39333

So a fish on an arc from the edge is considered to be moving in from "infinitely far away", meaning that when it is at the edge it is an infinite distance, as defined in this model, from the center.

Have you understood the article? You may need to read more about this:

I am not a rigorous mathematician. For me, if point A is "infinitely far away" from B then the distance between point A and point B is infinity.
 
I am not a rigorous mathematician. For me, if point A is "infinitely far away" from B then the distance between point A and point B is infinity.
Yes, and as defined in this (Poincaré disk) model, that's what it is. The edge of the circle is the "line at infinity", so the disk is the entire hyperbolic plane.

See

Euclidean intuition can be misleading because the scale of the model increases to infinity at the boundary circle.


Throughout this chapter the unit circle will be called the circle at infinity, denoted by S1. Of course, the circle at infinity is not included in the hyperbolic plane D but bounds it.

For more about Escher's understanding of the image (which apparently is not all correct), see
 
Top