erincalc said:it's a multiple choice question:
The function y=ln x+2 has a y-intercept at y=?
a)0
b)1
c)2
d)e
e)there is no y-intercept[/i]
tkhunny said:...or, if y = ln(x+2), what is ln(0+2)?
Feel free to write more clearly. Parentheses usually help.
pka said:Daniel Feldman,
While you are correct about looking at the options to determine the meaning ln x+2, my question is why should we have to?
Why don’t we insist that posters correctly use function notation.
After all, isn’t part of our mission the teaching of proper notation?
Why do we accept ln x and not insist upon ln(x)?
Why do we accept sin x and not insist upon sin(x)?
Again, after all, each of these is a function!
pka said:But we could say that we will not answer until you tell us is it
ln(x+2) or ln(x)+2?
Granted. However, if it came home on a worksheet or exam like that, I'd argue it with the teacher. Printed materials do have errors from time to time. This would be particularly important if "None of the Above" was listed as a choice. It would be the guess-what-was-in-the-teacher's-mind game. Very bad.Daniel_Feldman said:ln(2) is not a choice, so we can forgive it. Or not