(x-2)(x-4)(x-6)(x-8)=-15
should i open?
how do i start?
I believe that it is possible to simplify Mark's solution.
When dealing with polynomials, it is frequently helpful to narrow the range of possible solutions.
So first I would observe that if x is real, it must be greater than two. Why? And secondly I would observe that if x is real, it must be less than 8. Why?
OK we now know that if x is real 2 < x < 8.
Now that I have some general idea what I am looking for, I'd do what Mark did.
\(\displaystyle (x-2)(x-4)(x-6)(x-8)=-15 \implies f(x) = (x-2)(x-4)(x-6)(x-8) + 15 = 0 .\)
Now by inspection f(x) is a quartic polynomial with
integer coefficients, which means that the rational root theorem may apply. To apply the rational root theorem I need to know
only the coefficient of the highest power and the constant term. The constant term is
(-2)(-4)(-6)(-8) + 15 = 384 + 15 = 399. The coefficient of the highest power is obviously 1 so I am dealing with the integer root theorem, which says that
if there is a rational root, it will be 1, a prime factor of 399, or one of their additive inverses. But the additive inverses and 1 can be ignored because we already know that the answer (if it exists) must be between 2 and 8. And 399 has only 3 prime factors, namely 3, 7, and 19. But 19 can be ignored as a solution because 19 > 8. See how handy it can be to know where to look.
Now go back to the original equation and try 3 and 7.
(3 - 2)(3 - 4)(3 - 6)(3 - 8) = 1 * (-1) * (- 3) * (- 5) = - 15. So 3 is a solution.
(7 - 2)(7 - 4)(7 - 6)(7 - 8) = 5 * 3 * 1 * (-1) = - 15. So 7 is a solution.
Now I'd expand:
\(\displaystyle f(x) = (x-2)(x-4)(x-6)(x-8) + 15 = (x^2 - 6x + 8)(x^2 - 14x + 48) + 15 =\)
\(\displaystyle x^4 + (-14 - 6)x^3 + (48 + 8)x^2 + (-6 * 48 - -14 * 8)x + 8 * 48 + 15 =\)
\(\displaystyle x^4 - 20x^3 + 56x^2 - 400x + 399 = 0.\) Notice that the coefficient of \(\displaystyle x^3 = -20.\)
Now Mark uses the fundamental theorem of algebra and so would I.
\(\displaystyle f(x) = (x - 3)(x - 7)(px^2 + qx + r) = (x^2 - 10x + 21)(px^2 + qx + r) = 0.\)
But we already know that the coefficient of \(\displaystyle x^4 = 1\ and\ 21r = 399 \implies p = 1\ and\ r = \dfrac{399}{21} = 19.\)
\(\displaystyle So f(x) = (x^2 - 10x + 21)(x^2 + qx + 19) = x^4 + (q - 10)x^3 + z.\)
So \(\displaystyle q - 10 = - 20 \implies q = -10.\)
Now using the zero product property I know that the real solutions are 3, 7 and the real solutions (if there are any) such that
\(\displaystyle 2 < x < 8\ and\ x^2 - 10x + 19 = 0.\)
\(\displaystyle x^2 - 10x + 19 = 0 \implies x = \dfrac{10 \pm \sqrt{100 - 4 * 1 * 19}}{2} = \dfrac{10 \pm \sqrt{6 * 4}}{2} = 5 \pm \sqrt{6}.\)
\(\displaystyle 0 < \sqrt{6} < 3 \implies - 3 < - \sqrt{6} < 0 < \sqrt{6} < 3 \implies 2 < 5 - \sqrt{6} < < 5 < 5 + \sqrt{6} < 8.\)
Now CHECK
\(\displaystyle (5 - \sqrt{6} - 2)(5 - \sqrt{6} - 4)(5 - \sqrt{6} - 6)(5 - \sqrt{6} - 8) = (3 - \sqrt{6})(1 - \sqrt{6})(-1 - \sqrt{6})(-3 - \sqrt{6}) =\)
\(\displaystyle (3 - \sqrt{6})(- 3 - \sqrt{6})(1 - \sqrt{6})(-1 - \sqrt{6}) = (- 9 + 6)(-1 + 6) = - 3 * 5 = - 15.\) That checks.
\(\displaystyle (5 + \sqrt{6} - 2)(5 + \sqrt{6} - 4)(5 + \sqrt{6} - 6)(5 + \sqrt{6} - 8) = (3 + \sqrt{6})(1 + \sqrt{6})(-1 + \sqrt{6})(-3 + \sqrt{6}) =\)
\(\displaystyle (3 + \sqrt{6})(- 3 + \sqrt{6})(1 + \sqrt{6})(-1 + \sqrt{6}) = (- 9 + 6)(-1 + 6) = - 3 * 5 = - 15.\) That checks.
This is not an easy problem. If you are given a similar problem on a test, you will need to know how to solve it efficiently. I find my method of solving it to be a bit simpler than Mark's, but it really is using his ideas plus the idea of putting some bounds on the possible answers before starting. The bounds let you reduce the number of possibilities that need to be tested.