Agreed.
Note to student: It is a VERY COMMON error to ASSUME one knows what is going on in an interest rate problem. Without a VERY CLEAR definition, it is very difficult to arrive at a unique answer. It is quite possible that you discussed specifics in your class. The problem statement you provided simply does not contain sufficient detail for a substantive argument in any direction. It is just this confusion that make many, many financial service company's customers very unhappy. Truthfully, I gave up on one customer, many years ago. I told him to go down to any large department store and buy a calculator with an exponent button. Surely it would be less than $10. When he had that in his hand, he could call me back. He wasn't getting it. I think he didn't call me back.