I believe the closest example in my book (Stewart's Single Variable Calculus 7th edition) is as follows-
Page 358, Example 6
"Find the volume of the solid obtained by rotating the region in Example 4 about the line x = -1."
Example 4's problem was
"The region R enclosed by the curves y=x and y=x2 is rotated about the x-axis. Find the volume of the resulting solid"
Example 6's Solution
"Figure 11 shows a horizontal cross-section. It is a washer with inner radius 1+y and outer radius 1+ sqrt(y), so the cross-sectional area is
A(y) = (pi)[outer radius)2] - (pi)[(inner radius)2]
It then goes on to show the math and figure.
The figure has the line x = -1 drawn which I have replicated by drawing the line in my problem of x=2.
To account for the central axis shift from 0 to -1, the example problem adds 1 to the radii.
I followed that (first incorrectly by adding 2) by subtracting 2. This part I feel pretty confident I have right. Which means my error has to be related to the radii.