Antiderative

shahar

Full Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2018
Messages
508
I try in antiderative calculator to calculate the antiderative of sinx/x. I can't get an answer. Why is the reason to that error?
 
I try in antiderative calculator to calculate the antiderative of sinx/x. I can't get an answer. Why is the reason to that error?
There is no closed form for this indefinite integral. You can, perhaps, get some exact answers for definite integrals (I haven't looked to see if there are any simple ones for this.)

If you need a form to use, expand sin(x) into a Taylor series about the point of interest, then integrate the series. You won't be able to write the summation as a function, but it will give you a form you can use to estimate it.

-Dan
 
I can't get [a calculator to provide an] answer. Why is the reason to that error?
Hi shahar. Dan explained why (there's no formula), and the reason the calculator returned an "error" response is because it hasn't been programmed with algorithms to handle the situation.

Several computer algebra systems define a named function to handle the form [imath]\int{\frac{sin(x)}{x}}[/imath]. For example, my copy of MapleV would show the first derivative of f(x)=2*x*sin(x^2-1)/(x^2-1) as Si(x^2-1), and integrating Si(x^2-1) would return f(x). One could do calculations with Complex numbers or look at graphs with Real values.

I seem to remember using Si(x) in college, maybe, with Fourier transforms. (For the most part, those synapses have blissfully dissolved away.) :)
[imath]\;[/imath]
 
would show the first derivative of f(x)=2*x*sin(x^2-1)/(x^2-1) as Si(x^2-1), and integrating Si(x^2-1) would return f(x)
Whoops, I typed that inversely. :rolleyes: I meant, integrating f(x) gives Si(x) and differentiating Si(x) returns f(x).

I checked wolframalpha.com, and they also use the name Si(x). They even have a named function for the ratio of sin(x) to x: sinc(x). We can graph my example with plot {Si(x^2-1), 2*x*sinc(x^2-1)}.

Si-sinc.png
 
Top